*** Advanced Project Notice ***
The following project is an ADVANCED project and may require handling of dangerous materials and/or equipment and is intended to be conducted by adults only!
To compare the ability to remove microorganisms by germicidal soaps and non germicidal soaps.
There are two types of microbial flora on our skin; resident flora and transmitted flora. Resident flora lives permanently on our skin. Most of the skin residing microorganisms feed on skin secretions and live in harmony. They cause no diseases or adversary conditions to humans. But some of them are opportunistic pathogens. Means although they live in harmony, they can cause adversities to humans when an individual is deprived of natural immunity; especially when suffers with another disease condition. Resident flora is an essential part of our skin. They even help us to protect from skin pathogens by competitive inhibition.
Transmitted flora contaminates our skin when we make contact with other objects, soil, water or air. By washing, we can easily remove transmitted flora but resident flora removes only after a thorough washing.
- Four sterile cotton buds
- Sterilized Petri dishes
- Sterilized pipettes
- Sterilized test tubes with stoppers
- Sterile distilled water(or you can use sterile peptone water as your diluent)
- Pipette bulbs
- Bunsen burners
- Permanent marker
- Sterile liquid plate count agar medium
- Two soaps. Each from a germicidal brand and a non germicidal brand.
Estimated Experiment Time
Sterilization of require materials – 3 hours
To carry out the experiment – about 3 hours
Incubation period – 2 to 3 days
- 1. Prepare all the sterilized glass ware and microbiological media (in this case “total plate count agar”) prier to the experiment.
- a. Wrap all the glass instruments individually (pipettes and Petri dishes can wrap into sets) with news papers or aluminum foils. Put them inside a hot air oven. Heat them at 160°C for about three hours to sterilize.
Total Plate count Agar*1 in conical flasks (plugged with non absorbent cotton wool swabs covered with foil paper or screw caps) must place in an autoclave to be sterilized at 120°C for about 15 minutes.
Place each cotton bud in a test tube. Plug the tubes. Sterilize using the autoclave.
- 2. Ask your friend to do some day today works to get her/him hands dirty. Mark 1”x1” areas in both her/his hands.
- 3. Go to a sterile area (a Laminar flow / between two Bunsen flames).
- 4. Take out one cotton bud. Moisten it with sterile distilled water. Swab the marked area in his/her right hand for about one minute.
- 5. Cut and remove the plastic stem of cotton bud with a sterile pair of scissors*2;. Put the cotton swab into a test tube containing 10ml of sterile distilled water. Plug the test tube. Mix it thoroughly with a vortex or do it manually. Label this test tube as zero dilution.
- 6. Prepare a dilution series up to 10-7 * 3.
- 7. Plate 1ml of each dilution with plate count agar *4.
- 8. Wash your friend’s right hand with flowing tap water for 10 seconds. Then scrub for about 1 minute with the non germicidal soap. Wash again with tap water for 30 seconds.
- 9. Now mark a new 1 square inch area not overlapping with previously marked area. Continue the steps 3 to 7 with marked area after washing.
- 10. Repeat the above procedure (steps 3-9 with the marked area in your friend’s left hand. This time use the germicidal soap to wash the hand.
- 11. Put the inoculated plates for incubation for 2-3 days in inverted position.
- 12. After the incubation period count the isolated colonies in each plate. To determined no. of bacteria in each sample, pick the dilution plate with a colony count of 30-300 (You should select the plate with highest number of colonies in range of 30 -300). If the colony count is X use the following equation to calculate the number of colony forming units (bacterial cells or cell clusters/fungal spores) in the sample.
- 13. No. of CFU in 1g of soil= X * 10 / Dilution
- 14. Using the colony count compare the no. of microorganisms in 1 square inch of right and left hands before and after washing.
- 15. Now you can determine which soap has removed microorganisms more. To get the conclusion we assume that all the areas of two hands were equally dirty.
*1 You can prepare “Total Plate Count Agar” by following the instructions given in the label of commercial TPCA medium bottle or prepare the medium manually by following the recipe given in general microbiology books or microbiological media composition manuals.
*2 Metal objects like scissors can be sterilized by boiling or simply dip it in alcohol and flame a second until the alcohol layer on the object burns .
*3 Decant 1ml from the zero dilution into a test tube containing 9ml of sterile distilled water (in sterile conditions). Plug the test tube. Mix thoroughly. Name the tube as 10-1dilutiion. Likewise using a 1 ml from 10-1dilutiion, prepare 10-2 dilution. Continue the procedure until you get a dilution series up to 10-8.
*4 Pipette out 1 ml from 10° dilution into a Petri dish labeled as °. Repeat this with other dilutions. Do not forget to label the plate with the other information as from which hand you took the sample, what is the media that you add inside, date …etc. Mark these details in the bottom edge of the Petri dish (not on the lid). Use abbreviations.
Usually we place liquid agar media in 50°C incubator to keep them as liquids. Keep until cool down to about 40°C. Pour approximately 15 ml of nutrient agar in to each of the plates containing 1ml of microbial solutions. Mix the medium and culture in Petri plate by slowly applying circular (clockwise and anti clockwise) and linear (back and fore) moments.
After the calculations you will see that the germicidal soap removes more bacteria than the non germicidal soap.
Did you know that the meaning of “germicidal” is killing germs? Germicidal soaps contain antimicrobial agents to kill microbial contaminants on our skin. Therefore they are more effective in removing microorganisms than non germicidal soaps. But you don’t have to remove non germicidal soaps from your bath rooms. Remember, the resident flora lives in harmony with us. Removing all the friendly microorganisms can cause health problems. Germicidal soaps are useful to get our selves clean after doing works and playing outdoors, before food processing, before doing operations by doctors...etc.
Take a moment to visit our table of Periodic Elements page where you can get an in-depth view of all the elements,
complete with the industry first side-by-side element comparisons!